Sturdy metal pans, or a simple rimmed sheet pan, are optimal when cooking with a broiler. If you use something else (like a glass pan), it could crack or break under the broiler's heat.

What can I use if I don't have a broiler pan?

The best substitute for a broiling pan is a roasting tray with a wire rack insert. You can use the roasting tray as-is, but the wire rack helps the juice separate from the food. Other useful alternatives include cast-iron griddle pans and sheets, roasting trays, baking sheets, and aluminum trays.

Do you need a special pan to broil?

At cook time, you will need either a broiler pan (these usually come with your oven), which features slats to help air circulate for even cooking. ... Due to the extremely high heat of a broiler, glass cookware is not recommended.

What pans are safe for broiling?

Unless your nonstick cookware or bakeware explicitly says "broiler safe" or "safe up to 550°F," your best bet is to choose all-metal pans such as stainless steel or seasoned cast iron.

Can you use aluminum pans under the broiler?

Rather than always putting down a sheet of aluminum foil on a sturdy broiler pan, you can also use a disposable aluminum foil pan. Foil pans can be purchased inexpensively at supermarkets and then used as a standard broiler pan; there's no messy scrubbing or cleanup.

How to Broil

21 related questions found

Can you broil in a foil pan?

If you don't have a nonstick pan or you are cooking messy foods, you can line the top and bottom parts of the broiler pan with regular or nonstick aluminum foil. For the top part of the broiler pan, be sure to cut slits through the foil so fat can drain.

Can I broil in a glass pan?

Do not put glass under the broiler, even if it's strong and enforced, like Pyrex. It could break and that is just a mess you do not want to deal with. Instead, use a sturdy metal pan that can stand the heat. ... A rimmed sheet pan will also do the trick.

Can I use a cookie sheet to broil?

We've established in this post that most cookie sheets are broiler-safe- if they're made of a metal like stainless steel or heavy aluminum. Cast iron is also acceptable, as well as disposable aluminum pans. Remember not to use parchment paper in your broiler—instead, line with aluminum foil.

Is a broiler pan the same as a roasting pan?

Broiling pans are shallower and have a slotted base, while roasting pans are deeper in size. Broiler pans allow food to cook more quickly and allow drippings of the meat to drain underneath the meat itself; while roasting pans allow meat to cook in its own juices.

Can you broil with parchment paper?

While parchment paper is heat resistant, it's not heat proof. If it gets too close to a top-down broiler, it could ignite. It's best to use foil to line your broiler tray.

Does my oven have a broiler?

If your oven is electric, your broiler will typically be inside of your oven. ... If there are heating coils on the top and the bottom of the oven, then you have an in-oven broiler. If you have an oven heated with natural gas, the broiler is usually the drawer below the oven. To be sure, pull open the door.

What kind of pan do you broil steak in?

Step 2 Place a dry cast-iron skillet in a pre-heated broiler on high heat about 6 inches from flame or heating element. Heat pan for about 20 minutes. Step 3 Brush the steaks with olive oil and rub with coarse kosher or sea salt and freshly ground pepper. Step 4 CAUTION: Pan handle will be extremely hot.

Whats a broiler pan look like?

Typically constructed of stainless steel or heavy gauge steel with a black porcelain enamel, Broiler Pans consist of two sections, a low walled pan section and an upper cooking surface that is the broiler plate lid.

Can you put meat directly on oven rack?

Put a pan of any sort on the foil-lined rack. You can stick your meat scraps and bones, aromatics, wine, and/or stock in the pan—this is where the drippings will drip. Put your well-oiled roast (and that means your rib roast, but also pork crown roast, turkey, chicken, leg of lamb) on the top rack.

Can I use baking sheet instead of broiler pan?

Sturdy metal pans, or a simple rimmed sheet pan, are optimal when cooking with a broiler. If you use something else (like a glass pan), it could crack or break under the broiler's heat. Our Test Kitchen's favorite sheet pan is always a good bet.

How do you improvise a broiler pan?

Make a few foil balls by crumpling the aluminum sheet and cover the entire bottom of the broiler pan substitute with them. Place the meat over the foil balls and cook. You can use any metal pan for the broiling purpose as long as it does not warp under high heat.

How do you broil steak on a cookie sheet?

Preheat oven to broil. Season steaks with salt and pepper, to taste, and place onto the opposite side of the prepared baking sheet in a single layer. Place into oven and broil until the steak is browned and charred at the edges, about 4-5 minutes per side for medium-rare, or until desired doneness.

Can you broil in a ceramic dish?

Ceramic is one of the best cookware materials for withstanding high temperatures. ... The thicker the ceramic dish, the more thoroughly the heat will be distributed throughout the food. Broil with this tough dishware without burning yourself or breaking a valuable piece of your cookware.

What temperature do you broil at?

What temperature is broil? Some ovens will have one broil option, which is typically 500°F to 550°F, while others will let you select between low, med and high or even key in the temperature yourself. Low is usually 400°F, medium 450°F and high ranges from 500°F to 550°F.

Can I put pyrex in the oven?

Bottom Line: Pyrex Is Safe in a Preheated Oven

The most important thing to remember about Pyrex cookware is that while the glassware is oven-safe, the plastic lids are not. Additionally, be cautious to avoid thermal shock. ... Always preheat your oven before inserting Pyrex glassware. Never exceed 425°F.

Should you keep the oven door open when broiling?

The normal practice is to leave the oven door slightly ajar. This allows heat to escape and forces the broil element to stay on rather than cycling off and on. Open door broiling is good for when you are broiling for short periods of time, like cooking thinner meats, top browning or searing meat.

Can you cook a steak on a cookie sheet?

Lightly oil a baking sheet or coat with nonstick spray. ... Season steaks with salt and pepper, to taste, and add to the baking sheet in a single layer. Place into oven and broil until the steak is browned and charred at the edges, about 4-5 minutes per side for medium-rare, or until desired doneness.

What's the difference between broiling and grilling?

Loosely speaking grilling and broiling refer to a similar cooking process. In grilling, the heat source is below (like with a barbecue grill); in oven broiling, it's above. Both grilling and broiling involve intense heat.

Which side of aluminum foil is toxic?

Many people believe that it matters which side is used up or down. The truth is that it makes no difference at all. The reason the two sides look different is due to the manufacturing process.